PSA vs BGS vs CGC – Which Grading Service is Best?
If you’re thinking about grading Pokémon cards, your choice of grading company matters. PSA, Beckett Grading Services (BGS), and Certified Guaranty Company (CGC) are the three biggest names — each with its own strengths, quirks, and fanbase.
This guide compares them side-by-side so you can choose the right one for your collection and goals.
1. PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)
Overview:
- Industry leader in trading card grading since 1991
- Known for wide market recognition and strong resale value
- Uses a 10-point scale without half grades
Pros:
- Strongest resale demand in Pokémon TCG
- Simple grading scale (no subgrades to confuse buyers)
- Large population report database
Cons:
- No subgrades, so less granular detail
- Turnaround times can be long in peak periods
➡ Browse our PSA graded Pokémon cards to see market examples.
2. Beckett Grading Services (BGS)
Overview:
- Known for its four subgrades: centering, corners, edges, surface
- Offers “Black Label” Pristine 10 for perfect subgrades — highly sought after
Pros:
- More detailed grading breakdown
- Black Label 10 slabs are among the most desirable in the hobby
- Strong reputation in both sports and TCG markets
Cons:
- Some collectors find subgrades confusing
- Resale demand is strong, but PSA generally outsells for equivalent cards
3. Certified Guaranty Company (CGC)
Overview:
- Newer to Pokémon grading but respected in collectibles
- Competitive pricing and faster turnaround than PSA or BGS in many cases
- Uses 10-point scale with half grades
Pros:
- Affordable grading fees
- Clear, modern slab design
- Rapid turnaround times
Cons:
- Lower resale demand compared to PSA/BGS
- Harder to cross-grade into PSA/BGS at equal value
4. Which One Should You Choose?
If you want top resale value: PSA is still the leader for Pokémon cards.
If you want grading detail: BGS’s subgrades give a clearer breakdown.
If you want speed and affordability: CGC offers good value with quick turnaround.
For most collectors, the decision depends on whether you’re grading for resale or personal enjoyment. And remember — you can always buy slabs pre-graded from trusted sources if you don’t want to submit yourself.
➡ Browse all graded Pokémon cards in our store or explore [raw Pokémon cards] if you prefer to grade them yourself.
